
Misplaced Loyalties
Deuteronomy 17:11 commands following the Sages “right or left.” These posts, written in 2018 and restored from the archive, work through the sources on what happens when a scholar is convinced they are wrong.
Part 1
Misplaced Loyalties: Erring in the Duty to Obey the Sages
Oct 27, 2018Is obeying the Sages still a mitzvah when you're sure they're wrong? A preface to a series on lo tasur, with the sources and the Chikrei Lev responsum behind it.
Part 2
Misplaced Loyalties I: Sources
Oct 28, 2018The Sifrei says to obey the Sages even if they call your right hand left. The Yerushalmi says only if right is right. The sources, side by side.
Part 3
Misplaced Loyalties II: The Ohr HaChaim's Distinction
Oct 30, 2018Must a scholar follow the Sages into eating what he's sure is forbidden? The Ohr HaChaim splits the difference: obey a command to act, but not a mere permission.
Part 4
Misplaced Loyalties III: The Radical Views of Nachmanides
Oct 31, 2018The Ramban says to eat what you're sure is forbidden fat if the Sanhedrin permits it. How far he takes obedience to the Sages, in his own words.
Part 5
Misplaced Loyalties IV: The Ramban and the Wrong Yom Kippur
Nov 3, 2018The Ramban says the Torah means whatever the Sages rule. So why did Rabbi Akiva comfort Rabbi Yehoshua with a different verse when he had to break his Yom Kippur?