Contents

Misplaced Loyalties: Erring in the Duty to Obey the Sages

Contents
From the archive
Originally published on the old WordPress version of this blog on October 27, 2018. Restored from the Wayback Machine.

I’ve often encountered a challenge when writing about topics that interest me – where I start writing without realizing how involved the topic is and how much time it will take to write something accessible to a general audience. As such, recently I’ve tried to write really short self-contained blog posts.

So it’s with some misgivings that I start writing about an extremely involved and contentious topic like the sugya of מצוה לשמוע לדברי חכמים. But at the end of the day, I want to write about things that interest me.

That said, some disclaimers must be made. This is a topic where a little knowledge is a dangerous thing, and I make no promises to finish this in a comprehensive way. Perhaps that is not responsible, but then again, I don’t claim to be a very responsible person. Of course, as always, I must say what goes without saying:

Even if I had intended for whatever I wrote to be authoritative – it would not be – because I am not an authority on anything. But I do not intend for anything I write to be authoritative at all – I am just thinking out loud – so even in the alternate reality where I was an authority on the subject matter, what I write here would not be authoritative.

To be well versed in the subject, besides knowing the relevant sugyot in Shas and the commentaries – there is a lengthy תשובה in the שו”ת חקרי לב about the matter. Depending on how far we go, we will likely reference it a lot and we may go into it at depth. It would make sense for anyone trying to really understand these matters to go through the תשובה.

Here is a link:

שו”ת חקרי לב א יו”ד סימן פ”ד

(It has been noted that the print in the Hebrewbooks.org copy of חקרי לב is not the clearest and most pristine, but it is the only one I know of that is publicly available online. If anyone knows of a link to a version with a better print – a link in the comments would be most appreciated.)

Some sources for the first post:
  1. Deuteronomy 17:11
  2. Bavli Bava Basra 47b – 48a
  3. Maimonides Hilchos Gerushim Chapter 2 Halacha 20
  4. Bavli Horayos 2b
  5. Yerushalmi Horayos Chapter 1 Halacha 1

Jacob Shore

Hi, I'm Jacob. I'm a language nerd, developer, and spiritual wanderer.

Related Content